This article is the second in a series of blog posts on Indico’s new Decision Era eBook, a comprehensive guide to how AI is reshaping the insurance landscape by enhancing decision-making processes across the policy lifecycle. This eBook sheds light on the many ways that AI-driven technologies are influencing the industry, helping insurers evolve beyond traditional automation and into a future of AI-enhanced decisioning.
Chapter 2, titled AI’s Role in Transforming Insurance, delves deeper into how AI is evolving from simple automation to dynamic, data-driven decision-making. In the sections that follow, the chapter unpacks how different forms of AI, and specifically agentic AI, are driving smarter, faster decisions in critical insurance areas such as underwriting, claims management, and risk assessment.
From automation to decision-making: AI’s evolving role in insurance
The early days of AI in insurance focused almost entirely on automating repetitive, labor-intensive tasks to improve efficiency and reduce operational costs. Basic forms of automation, such as robotic process automation (RPA), offered immediate gains by handling data entry, file management, and claims processing. For insurers, this meant reducing the workload for professionals and redirecting human resources toward more complex issues. However, these tools were limited by pre-programmed rules and static decision-making, requiring human intervention whenever unique or complex scenarios arose. While effective in minimizing routine tasks, RPA and IDP lacked the capacity to adapt in real-time or navigate more nuanced aspects of underwriting, risk assessment, and claims processing.
The Decision Era emphasizes that while these early forms of automation provided much-needed relief, they fell short of delivering the dynamic decision-making that insurance demands in an increasingly data-driven world. Automating manual processes was only the first step, and as industry needs evolved, the demand for a higher level of intelligence became clear. Beazley Digital Head of Technology James Wright highlights this shift, where he explains that companies are now integrating large language models (LLMs) to gain deeper insights into their data and reduce error rates. By implementing these models, Wright notes, Beazley Digital has seen about a 20% improvement in accuracy, illustrating how moving beyond basic automation has real, measurable benefits.
Today’s AI-driven technologies are bridging the gap between automation and intelligent decision-making by moving away from rigid rule-based systems. Instead of just expediting tasks, AI now supports real-time decision-making processes, helping insurers make strategic, data-informed choices on the spot. This evolution goes beyond automating individual workflows; it introduces a system that can adapt to changing data and contribute to outcomes that would otherwise rely solely on human judgment. This shift represents a fundamental change in how insurers operate, allowing them to respond more rapidly to market fluctuations, client needs, and emerging risks.
AI is increasingly becoming less about automating specific tasks and more about enabling machines to make complex decisions autonomously. By evolving beyond traditional RPA and IDP systems, AI can support processes that require active decision-making, risk analysis, and even pricing recommendations. This capability doesn’t just reduce operational burdens; it allows insurers to refocus their efforts from repetitive manual tasks to strategic, high-impact initiatives. For example, while RPA can extract and organize customer data, newer AI models can analyze that data in real-time, identify potential risk factors, and present tailored policy recommendations.
Related content: Unlocking the future of insurance: Exploring chapter 1 of Indico’s Decision Era eBook
The rise of agentic AI and generative AI in decision-making
The chapter then explores two transformative subsets of AI: agentic AI and generative AI, both of which are driving the insurance industry forward in remarkable ways. While earlier AI applications were largely limited to rule-based automation, these advanced AI models bring an entirely new level of functionality, enabling insurers to handle complex, data-driven decisions dynamically and in real time.
Agentic AI
Agentic AI, a form of autonomous artificial intelligence, stands out as a powerful tool for navigating complex industries and environments, as it can make independent decisions and interact with external systems to achieve specific objectives. Unlike traditional AI models that are confined by rigid, predefined rules, agentic AI has the flexibility to adapt and respond to changing data and evolving circumstances. This adaptability is particularly advantageous in underwriting, where risks and pricing can vary significantly from one policy to another.
Agentic AI goes beyond simply compiling and presenting data; it analyzes various risk factors, evaluates pricing options, and can even make suggestions on policy structures by drawing insights from previous cases. For instance, in situations involving high-value or complex insurance applications, agentic AI can autonomously assess the data to recommend tailored pricing models that balance profitability with customer needs, reducing the workload on underwriters while enhancing accuracy. In claims management, agentic AI can autonomously flag potential cases of fraud or high-risk claims, triggering an alert for further investigation without requiring human intervention. In doing so, it helps prevent unnecessary payouts and enhances compliance with regulatory standards, making the overall claims process more efficient and secure.
Generative AI
Meanwhile, generative AI (gen AI) complements agentic AI’s decision-making capabilities by producing new data insights that can help shape more informed decisions. Generative AI doesn’t just analyze existing data—it actively generates new content, scenarios, and solutions based on historical data patterns. This capability has proven especially valuable in the context of policy pricing, where gen AI allows insurers to model a variety of “what-if” scenarios. For example, it can simulate how changes in market conditions might affect claim volumes or loss ratios, helping insurers prepare for various contingencies. This level of proactive insight allows insurers to adjust their strategies based on potential future events, thereby maintaining competitiveness and reducing exposure to unforeseen risks.
Generative AI’s value is also evident in customer-facing applications. For instance, insurers can use gen AI to create personalized policy offerings that reflect individual client needs and risk factors. By generating unique coverage options or customized policy suggestions, gen AI helps insurers deliver a more tailored customer experience. This is particularly beneficial for customers with complex insurance needs—such as those seeking commercial property coverage—where personalized options can make a significant difference in customer satisfaction and retention. In addition, gen AI’s ability to provide detailed, data-driven recommendations enables insurers to fine-tune their product offerings, increasing the relevance and appeal of their policies.
Agentic AI and gen AI work in tandem to streamline operations, reduce latency in decision-making, and foster more agile responses across the insurance cycle. For instance, while agentic AI can autonomously assess risk and suggest pricing, gen AI can provide additional insights by generating predictive models that reflect market conditions, helping underwriters make more precise adjustments. This collaboration between agentic and generative AI supports a more responsive and data-driven approach to decision-making, allowing insurers to remain competitive while managing risks effectively. By reducing the reliance on manual intervention and enabling continuous data-informed adjustments, these advanced AI models transform the insurance industry’s approach to both back-end processes and customer engagement.
The progression of AI: From predictive to autonomous models
To provide context on AI’s growth in insurance, the chapter next details how AI has evolved through several “waves.” Each new stage of AI’s development has built on the last to create more sophisticated decision-making capabilities. This progression includes four primary waves:
- Wave 1: Predictive AI – Insurers initially used predictive AI models to analyze historical data and forecast potential outcomes. In claims processing, for example, predictive AI could assess the likelihood of fraud based on previous claims patterns. This laid the groundwork for integrating data-driven insights into daily operations.
- Wave 2: Extractive AI – As AI advanced, extractive models were introduced to uncover value from unstructured data. These models could extract critical insights from large text sets, such as identifying relevant clauses in legal documents. For insurers, this enabled faster policy review and submission processing, enhancing efficiency in data-heavy tasks.
- Wave 3: Interpretive AI – Driven by large language models (LLMs), interpretive AI brought new levels of understanding to insurance operations. This wave allowed insurers to better interpret complex documents, emails, and policy information, facilitating more accurate risk assessments. Interpretive AI provided the foundation for more nuanced decision-making by offering context to previously opaque data points.
- Wave 4: Autonomous AI – Now, the industry is entering a phase where AI models, such as agentic AI, can operate with governance frameworks to ensure safe, autonomous decision-making. Autonomous AI doesn’t just analyze and interpret data—it actively makes decisions, adjusting risk profiles, predicting potential claims, and optimizing policy recommendations. With built-in governance protocols, insurers can leverage these capabilities without sacrificing regulatory compliance or oversight.
These waves have all impacted the insurance industry in vastly different ways, and each type of AI has had significantly different functions from the last—but it’s clear that every iteration of AI has significantly improved the industry in various ways. What’s more, agentic AI and the autonomous AI wave stand to influence the insurance industry in even greater ways than the past three movements have.
Related content: AI-enhanced decisioning: Transforming the insurance submission clearance process
Agentic AI’s emerging impact on underwriting, claims, and risk management
Chapter 2 of the eBook also highlights how the insurance industry is moving from basic process automation—like policy renewals and document management—to AI-driven decision-making in critical areas like underwriting, claims, and risk assessment. The chapter notes that 67% of insurers are currently piloting large language models to handle natural language processing and decision-making. This rapid adoption of advanced AI has allowed insurers to minimize manual intervention in underwriting, optimize workflows, and deliver more precise risk assessments.
The result? Decision-ready insights that insurers can use to optimize their portfolios, adjust pricing strategies in real-time, and reduce claims-related risks. By leveraging AI-driven insights, insurers are better positioned to grow premiums, improve loss ratios, and ensure faster response times in policy processing. The chapter underscores how AI’s ability to support high-level decisioning is transforming underwriting and claims management, ultimately leading to higher customer satisfaction and profitability.
Discover how AI transforms decision-making in insurance
Chapter 2 of The Decision Era eBook offers a deep dive into how AI has evolved from a tool for automating simple tasks to a technology capable of making complex, autonomous decisions. By incorporating agentic AI and generative AI, insurers can optimize key areas of the policy lifecycle, from underwriting to claims management.
For insurers looking to stay ahead in a competitive market, understanding and implementing AI-enhanced decisioning is essential. Download the eBook today to explore these transformative insights and see how Indico’s solutions can elevate your organization’s decision-making capabilities.
Subscribe to our LinkedIn newsletter.
Frequently asked questions
- What specific challenges do insurers face when implementing AI technologies like agentic and generative AI? The article touches on the benefits of AI but doesn’t detail the unique challenges insurers may encounter in adopting these technologies. Implementing AI in insurance involves significant challenges, including regulatory compliance, data privacy concerns, and the integration of new AI systems into legacy infrastructures. Insurers must navigate strict regulations while ensuring data security and system compatibility. Additionally, training staff and adjusting workflows to incorporate AI-driven decision-making can be resource-intensive and require a considerable cultural shift within the organization.
- How does agentic AI differ from interpretive AI in practical insurance applications? The blog describes the evolution of AI, but some readers might want a clearer comparison between agentic and interpretive AI within real-world insurance operations. Agentic AI allows for autonomous, decision-making processes that adapt in real-time without human intervention, making it highly effective in dynamic scenarios like risk assessments and fraud detection. Interpretive AI, however, focuses more on understanding and extracting meaning from data—useful for processing complex policy documents or customer communications. In practice, interpretive AI might help insurers better understand nuanced language in claims or contracts, while agentic AI can make recommendations or take action based on those interpretations, pushing decision-making to a new level.
- What role does AI play in enhancing customer satisfaction specifically? While the blog discusses efficiency improvements, readers might want to understand how these translate to customer experience. AI can significantly enhance customer satisfaction by streamlining processes like claims processing, providing real-time risk assessment, and offering personalized policy recommendations. Through generative AI, insurers can create tailored policy options that meet individual client needs, leading to faster, more responsive service. This personalized approach, combined with quicker, more accurate claims processing, reduces the waiting period for clients, making the experience smoother and fostering a stronger client relationship with the insurer.
