Upcoming Webinar

Better Data, Better Decisions: How AI and Automation Are Reshaping Risk and Pricing

March 31st at 10:00 AM ET

DAYS
HOURS
MINUTES
SECONDS
  Everest Group IDP
             PEAK Matrix® 2022  
Indico Named as Major Contender and Star Performer in Everest Group's PEAK Matrix® for Intelligent Document Processing (IDP)
Access the Report

BLOG

How to implement underwriting automation without disrupting your existing workflows

March 12, 2025 | Artificial Intelligence, Data Analytics, Data Science, Digital Transformation, Insurance, Insurance Claims, Insurance Underwriting, Intelligent Document Processing

Back to Blog

Implementing automation in underwriting doesn’t have to mean upheaval in your existing processes. With tools now available to streamline workflows and enhance decision-making, the challenge lies in integrating these solutions without causing workflow disruptions. 

This guide outlines how underwriting automation can be seamlessly incorporated into your operations so you can enjoy faster decisions, improved accuracy, and stronger bottom-line results without risking operational chaos.

Read our recent announcement here: Indico Data elevates insurance AI with out-of-the-box capabilities for global carriers

 

Why underwriting automation matters

 

Underwriting remains one of the most critical and time-intensive components of insurance operations. While balancing risk management and responsiveness, underwriters often face bottlenecks caused by manual processes and fragmented datasets. Automating parts of the underwriting workflow addresses these challenges, offering significant advantages:

  • Faster submissions processing: Automation can reduce processing times by up to 85% while allowing underwriters to focus on high-value activities.
  • Improved accuracy: When systems assist in identifying trends or flagging inconsistencies in data, there’s less room for error.
  • Scalability: Automation enables carriers to handle higher volumes, even during peak submission periods.
  • Enhanced customer satisfaction: Faster responses to brokers and clients help maintain strong relationships.

But, automation is only effective when it’s implemented well. Poorly integrated systems can lead to inefficiencies, user frustration, and even compliance risks. The key is adopting robust automation solutions while preserving the integrity of your workflows.

Related content: How AI-powered underwriting automation improves decision speed and accuracy 

 

Key approaches for seamless underwriting automation

 

Understand your existing workflows

Before introducing automation, it’s crucial to fully map out and understand your current underwriting processes. Identify:

  • Repetitive tasks: Where are your underwriters currently spending a disproportionate amount of time on manual work such as data entry or triaging submissions?
  • Systems and tools in use: Understand how existing tools like CRMs, policy management systems, and submissions databases tie into daily workflows.
  • Common inefficiencies: Highlight areas of delay, such as information rekeying across disconnected platforms or slow approval cycles.

This initial audit ensures you don’t inadvertently disrupt critical processes while implementing new automation tools.

Choose the right automation platform

Not all automation tools are created equal. Choosing the right solution requires evaluating platforms that seamlessly integrate with your existing systems, support your team’s goals, and offer long-term scalability. 

Start small with incremental changes

Rather than overhauling your entire underwriting process, begin by automating small segments of your workflow. For example:

  • Automate document ingestion and data capture from submissions like emails or PDFs.
  • Use priority scoring algorithms to automatically triage and rank submissions that align with underwriter preferences.
  • Employ AI-powered tools to flag incomplete submissions or inconsistencies requiring manual review.

By implementing incremental changes, you make it easier for teams to adjust, identify bugs early, and measure immediate ROI.

Collaborate with your underwriters

Successful automation isn’t just about the technology; it’s about how teams use it. Engage underwriters in the automation process by:

  • Training sessions: Help them understand how automation enhances their workflows rather than replaces their expertise.
  • Feedback loops: Create a feedback system so underwriters can share challenges and suggestions for fine-tuning the tools.

By involving your underwriting team at every stage, you build trust and encourage buy-in for new systems.

Integrate data across platforms

Fragmented data often results in inefficiencies. A successful automation system functions best when all underwriting-relevant information—from claims histories to submissions details—is integrated into a single accessible platform.

Solutions like Indico Data allow insurers to automate the unbundling, classification, and extraction of data across systems while eliminating redundancies. For example, automating submissions intake allows data from multiple sources, such as PDFs and spreadsheets, to be consolidated into a unified view for underwriters.

Ensure scalability and flexibility

Finally, successful automation systems should adapt as your business grows. The chosen platform should not only handle current underwriting volumes but also enable scalability during peak seasons or as you expand your business into new lines of coverage or geographies.

Build for compliance and transparency

Automation can enhance transparency, especially when paired with robust auditing features. Many underwriters face increasing pressure from regulators to provide detailed records of decision-making processes. Automated tools like Indico Data include audit trails to document key decisions, which helps insurers maintain compliance.

Related content: From submission to clearance: how automation is changing insurance submission triage 

 

Real-world benefits of automation in underwriting

 

The tangible impact of successful underwriting automation extends beyond improved efficiency:

  • Enhanced risk assessment 

AI enables underwriters to analyze risk using richer data sets, improving pricing accuracy and portfolio allocation.

  • Stronger customer relationships 

By speeding up quotes and resolving issues faster, automation helps carriers provide better experiences to brokers and clients alike. 

  • Reduced operational costs 

By minimizing manual workloads, automation allows insurers to allocate resources more effectively and focus on strategic growth. 

 

Next steps for automation in underwriting

 

The days of manual underwriting processes are numbered. Implementing AI-based automation can transform your workflows, streamline operations, and deliver measurable ROI without unnecessary disruptions to your existing systems. 

Start your automation transformation by auditing your processes, prioritizing integration-ready platforms, and incrementally introducing automation across tasks like document ingestion, triage, and data analysis.

Learn how Indico Data’s decision automation platform is equipping insurers worldwide with the tools to thrive in the future of underwriting. Explore their solutions and insights by scheduling a demo!

Don’t just adapt to modern underwriting’s challenges. Lead the charge toward smarter, faster, and more efficient decision-making. 

Register for our upcoming webinar: Better Data, Better Decisions: How AI and Automation Are Reshaping Risk and Pricing, March 31st at 10:00 AM ET

Subscribe to our LinkedIn newsletter.

Frequently asked questions

  • How long does it typically take to implement underwriting automation, and what are the key phases? The timeline varies based on company size, existing infrastructure, and the complexity of the solution. Typically, the process starts with assessment and planning, which takes two to four weeks. This involves identifying inefficiencies, setting goals, and selecting the right tools. Integration and testing follow, taking anywhere from two to six months, depending on the complexity of the automation and how well it integrates with existing workflows. Training and adoption usually take one to two months, focusing on educating underwriters, gathering feedback, and making necessary adjustments. Full deployment and ongoing optimization come last, where automation expands into additional workflows, and refinements are made based on real-world usage.
  • What are the most common challenges companies face when integrating underwriting automation? One of the biggest challenges is resistance to change, as underwriters may hesitate to adopt new technology, fearing job displacement or added complexity. Engaging them early and showing how automation enhances efficiency rather than replaces expertise helps ease concerns. Integration with legacy systems is another issue, as many insurers rely on outdated platforms that don’t easily connect with modern automation tools. Selecting solutions with flexible APIs or middleware can bridge these gaps. Poor data quality is also a major hurdle, as automation relies on structured and accurate information. AI-driven data extraction tools can help process emails, PDFs, and even handwritten documents. Regulatory compliance remains a concern, requiring insurers to ensure their automation tools include audit trails and compliance tracking.
  • How can insurers measure the success of underwriting automation? Success is measured through several key factors. Time savings is one of the most immediate indicators, with reduced manual processing time for submissions and approvals. Accuracy improvements become evident as automation decreases errors and inconsistencies in risk assessment. Operational efficiency improves as underwriters handle a higher volume of applications. Customer and broker satisfaction increases with faster response times and better service. Cost reductions follow, as automation lowers the need for manual labor and reduces rework. Compliance and risk management also improve, as automated systems provide clearer audit trails and reduce regulatory issues.
[addtoany]

Increase intake capacity. Drive top line revenue growth.

[addtoany]

Resources

Blog

Gain insights from experts in automation, data, machine learning, and digital transformation.

Unstructured Unlocked

Enterprise leaders discuss how to unlock value from unstructured data.

YouTube Channel

Check out our YouTube channel to see clips from our podcast and more.
Subscribe to our blog

Get our best content on intelligent automation sent to your inbox weekly!